| Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? | |
|
+4Robinsgirl bethandmanly Docfan LM 8 posters |
Author | Message |
---|
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| Subject: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:47 am | |
| I was curious to know what the descendents of the real Ingalls family thought/think of the TV series.
Does anyone know of how they felt about so many changes...mostly extra storylines to keep the series running? What about things like adding adopted children, Mary getting married and having a baby (actually losing two).
If you've all discussed this before and don't feel like getting into it again, would someone be kind enough to post the link that leads to it on the forum?
Thank you. | |
|
| |
Docfan New Pioneer
Number of posts : 225 Location : north Georgia Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:30 am | |
| I don't have any answers for you, but I have wondered that too. I've never read about any bad feelings about the show amongst any Ingalls descendants though.... | |
|
| |
bethandmanly Dean's Dedicated Diva
Number of posts : 7600 Location : In a book Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:58 am | |
| I'll see if Beth Ingalls-Leisses will be willing to pop in and answer your question. I'm pretty sure she's a member here, but Marilyn is the one who is close to her. Poor Marilyn has been suffering with this mysterious ailment for so long that I don't know when she'll be coming back this way. | |
|
| |
Guest Guest
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Mon Jan 12, 2009 5:26 am | |
| Great topic ...I too would love to know the opinions of any real descendants |
|
| |
Robinsgirl Frontier Traveler
Number of posts : 329 Location : Ohio Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Mon Jan 12, 2009 11:04 am | |
| I bet they are really proud that an entire hit TV show was aired about their decendents. I know I would be so happy and proud if one of my family touched so many people like Laura did. She was an amazing person. Sometimes life throws you under the bus. You gotta hold on for dear life. Don't waste one single day. ============================================================================================== I wonder how I find myself with the greatest boy ever! <3 He loves me in spite of my issues. | |
|
| |
I Love Dean Frontier Traveler
Number of posts : 329 Location : Deanland Wisconsin Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Mon Jan 12, 2009 2:49 pm | |
| I can't speak for Beth Ingalls personally but here is a great interview done by Lennon Parker (Prairiefans.com) with Beth. Some of the questions he asked are similar to some of your questions. Beth IngallsP.S. the picture of the tall blonde in the prairie dress is me... | |
|
| |
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| |
| |
Teresa Ingalls Friend for Life
Number of posts : 5286 Location : Minnesota Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Tue Jan 13, 2009 3:25 pm | |
| It was a blessing to have someone like Michael Landon write and produce this television series. He made it such a wonderful, family oriented show. It's amazing how much this series touched so many lives, and still does today. It's clearly in a league all of it's own. | |
|
| |
Gin Ingalls Friend for Life
Number of posts : 5920 Location : Curled up with a great book. Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Tue Jan 13, 2009 4:11 pm | |
| I often thought of this too. I even wrote a fan fiction posted on Prairiefans called A Priceless Tour. It took place in Laura and Almanzo's home in Mansfield. In the story I found myself locked inside the home after hours and I run across Laura and Manly's "ghost". As I'm talking to Laura I ask her about the TV show. Look it up....it was my first so I'm sure I needed to do more...but I was proud of it. I looked up this story....its on Prairiefans...fan fiction...pg 18 in two parts If you are interested in reading it. It is the lack of Christianity that has brought us where we are. Not a lack of churches or religious forms but of the real thing in our hearts. LIW.....Words From a Fearless Heart | |
|
| |
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 15, 2009 12:30 pm | |
| - Teresa wrote:
- It was a blessing to have someone like Michael Landon write and produce this television series. He made it such a wonderful, family oriented show. It's amazing how much this series touched so many lives, and still does today. It's clearly in a league all of it's own.
Very true, and I agree. | |
|
| |
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 15, 2009 12:31 pm | |
| - Gin wrote:
- I often thought of this too. I even wrote a fan fiction posted on Prairiefans called A Priceless Tour. It took place in Laura and Almanzo's home in Mansfield. In the story I found myself locked inside the home after hours and I run across Laura and Manly's "ghost". As I'm talking to Laura I ask her about the TV show. Look it up....it was my first so I'm sure I needed to do more...but I was proud of it.
I looked up this story....its on Prairiefans...fan fiction...pg 18 in two parts If you are interested in reading it. Thanks. I might take a peek someday. | |
|
| |
Samantha New Pioneer
Number of posts : 199 Location : San Francisco Mood :
| |
| |
Gin Ingalls Friend for Life
Number of posts : 5920 Location : Curled up with a great book. Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 29, 2009 3:28 pm | |
| I do agree with you Samantha. I seperate books and show as well. I think Laura might not have thought of putting " May we make them Proud" in amoung the shows. It didn't really happen to Mary. Although, I have a collection of articles from the newsletter issued by the LIW memorial society. It is called "The Best of the LORE". One of the articles is entitled "On writing the Little House Series." (This article was written by LIW) In it she tells also of what she did NOT include in the series : A lady named Kate Bender and her two brothers owned a tavern. It was known that people who would stop there seemed to disappear. The Benders garden was always freshly plowed and later there where several bodies found in that garden. This was just one of several sad stories that I'm sure Mary and Laura heard of, but Laura couldn't add in her books. There really were awful things that happend just as "Sylvia". Laura wanted to only reflect on the good things.
If you all haven't read "Lore" do get it. Its a fascinating read, and a very good collectors item. ($19.95) It is the lack of Christianity that has brought us where we are. Not a lack of churches or religious forms but of the real thing in our hearts. LIW.....Words From a Fearless Heart | |
|
| |
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 29, 2009 3:59 pm | |
| - Samantha wrote:
- In my mind, I make a point to separate Michael's Landon's Little House series from the books. While he did capture some of the book's spirit, Landon had a dark side that manifested itself into the television series. I think Laura Ingalls Wilder might have taken issue with episodes like "May We Make Them Proud", "Sylvia", and "The Aftermath." Furthermore, Laura may not have been pleased with episodes like "The Handman" that hinted at infidelity on Caroline's part.
I love Michael's Landon's Little House series and all the drama and romance that comes with it. However, I don't consider the series a reflection of the experiences of the real Laura Ingalls Wilder. I always wondered why he went that route. I figured he wanted to keep raitings up reaching people who wouldn't normally watch the show. With the promos of those episodes being played, they were sure to catch many an eye. Though such events are a part of our world, I don't think they would have been missed if not made into eps for the show. | |
|
| |
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 29, 2009 4:01 pm | |
| - Gin wrote:
- I do agree with you Samantha. I seperate books and show as well. I think Laura might not have thought of putting " May we make them Proud" in amoung the shows. It didn't really happen to Mary.
Although, I have a collection of articles from the newsletter issued by the LIW memorial society. It is called "The Best of the LORE". One of the articles is entitled "On writing the Little House Series." (This article was written by LIW) In it she tells also of what she did NOT include in the series : A lady named Kate Bender and her two brothers owned a tavern. It was known that people who would stop there seemed to disappear. The Benders garden was always freshly plowed and later there where several bodies found in that garden. This was just one of several sad stories that I'm sure Mary and Laura heard of, but Laura couldn't add in her books. There really were awful things that happend just as "Sylvia". Laura wanted to only reflect on the good things.
If you all haven't read "Lore" do get it. Its a fascinating read, and a very good collectors item. ($19.95) Ooh, that's an unpleasant story. There's no telling what all the family saw, heard and went through, you know? I don't see anything wrong with focusing on the good things in their lives for the show. | |
|
| |
bethandmanly Dean's Dedicated Diva
Number of posts : 7600 Location : In a book Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 29, 2009 5:23 pm | |
| - Gin wrote:
- I do agree with you Samantha. I seperate books and show as well. I think Laura might not have thought of putting " May we make them Proud" in amoung the shows. It didn't really happen to Mary.
Although, I have a collection of articles from the newsletter issued by the LIW memorial society. It is called "The Best of the LORE". One of the articles is entitled "On writing the Little House Series." (This article was written by LIW) In it she tells also of what she did NOT include in the series : A lady named Kate Bender and her two brothers owned a tavern. It was known that people who would stop there seemed to disappear. The Benders garden was always freshly plowed and later there where several bodies found in that garden. This was just one of several sad stories that I'm sure Mary and Laura heard of, but Laura couldn't add in her books. There really were awful things that happend just as "Sylvia". Laura wanted to only reflect on the good things.
If you all haven't read "Lore" do get it. Its a fascinating read, and a very good collectors item. ($19.95) I had heard this story before and it's quite disturbing. The thought of being exposed to things like that is spooky. Since the books are written from a young girl's and then a young woman's perspective, it's important that the view of the world be a romanticized. I think the reason that "The First Four Years" isn't a favorite for a lot of fans is because of how it was written. For the first time, Laura's healthy dose of optimism doesn't seem to carry her through the difficulties in life. As for the show, I think the modern day influence on the storylines can't be dismissed. In addition, though I didn't always like the darker episodes, they helped to portray some of the difficulties that families faced during that time period and some that still plague us today: infant mortality, rape, crime, epidemics, etc. I still remember reading about Laura's experience with her first teaching job and being freaked out over how she must have felt with the woman walking through the house with a knife. That for me, showed a bit of a turning point in the books where Laura was willing to add more to the stories of her growing up years than just optimism, and therefore, I guess I never questioned the darker LHOP episodes. One of my favorite episodes from Season 9 is "Rage"--which is when Tom Stark goes off the deep end and takes Laura, Rose, and Jenny hostage. Laura shows such presence of mind when dealing with Stark and in helping Jenny escape that I like to watch this episode because Laura's strength and intelligence really shine through. I can't imagine what the real Laura might have thought of this episode--the presence of Jenny, notwithstanding. | |
|
| |
Robinsgirl Frontier Traveler
Number of posts : 329 Location : Ohio Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Thu Jan 29, 2009 7:02 pm | |
| Interesting Sorty!! Sometimes life throws you under the bus. You gotta hold on for dear life. Don't waste one single day. ============================================================================================== I wonder how I find myself with the greatest boy ever! <3 He loves me in spite of my issues. | |
|
| |
LM Prairie Settler
Number of posts : 812 Location : Bama ~ USA ~ Planet Earth Mood :
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? Fri Jan 30, 2009 12:35 am | |
| - Quote :
- One of my favorite episodes from Season 9 is "Rage"--which is when Tom Stark goes off the deep end and takes Laura, Rose, and Jenny hostage. Laura shows such presence of mind when dealing with Stark and in helping Jenny escape that I like to watch this episode because Laura's strength and intelligence really shine through. I can't imagine what the real Laura might have thought of this episode--the presence of Jenny, notwithstanding.
Choosing from the "darker" eps, Rage is probably my fave. Another one that was off the track, IMO, was the one where the teen boy visits his grandparents after his mom could no longer handle him. He and his mom were abused by his father, and when his father died, the boy really went off kilter. Oh, one more - the one where the little boy moves in with Caroline and the girls while Charles helps the father to kick his addition to alcohol. It was a good ep, too. I like how strong the little boy was, though he'd been through the ringer. | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? | |
| |
|
| |
| Any real Ingalls unhappy about the show? | |
|