Breaking Amish

MissOleson wrote:

Whereas this one, I think, has given these people too much too fast (i.e. all of NYC) and naturally they are going to be more tempted to do "naughty" (for lack of a better word) things right away. I just can't understand why they would basically send these people, who have really not had any experience in a city before, to an extrememly city-like city. Do you know what I am saying? Am I making sense? I can't really think of the right words for it. But I think this whole experiment on TLC's part is silly.

Typical 'reality' TV, I guess...there's a lot more shock value placing them in NYC than say....Michigan. TLC played their cards right---they'll get plenty more viewers this way, that aren't looking for 'interesting', but rather 'shock'. Sad comment on our society, huh?!

This show is turning out to be totally fake. Shame on TLC...

Here are a few articles from one of our local news channels..

http://www.whptv.com/news/local/story/CBS-21-reveals-the-violent-secret-past-of-one-of/RsX1Nua6KEOkaYjR8-aFpA.cspx


http://www.whptv.com/news/local/story/Ex-wife-of-Breaking-Amish-cast-member-speaks-out/bRHFbzPreEGqgDdZqvtmCA.cspx

Pic ~ Rebecca and Abe w/ their child.. (When she still had her teeth)

I only watched it once and about fell over when the girl took her teeth out!
Yes, the language for me was the reason I turned it off.

I LOVE Beverly Lewis' fiction books based on the Amish, so my vision of them is not as this show has them appear. I'm sure there is alot of them that wants out, but to make things worse by putting cameras in front of them is just weird. They will be shunned now for life.
We need less reality shows of any kind. I'm sticking with the Hallmark channel.

Wow Debbie, thanks for the info

I do have to say that for people who had JUST left the amish, these people were pretty worldly and it amazes me how much Sabrina, Jeremiah and Kate cuss and how much they drink...
Jeremiah acts like a JERK! He is so immature, actually, they all seem to be.

Not cool... I am about to take this show of my list...

Buttercup wrote:

I thought Amish wore dark colors, not light colors. Are they Mennonites?


I will have check it out.

Amish and Mennonites are different, Amish are isolated from the "outside", Mennonites not so much so.

wow..just wow.so sad

alexczarn wrote:

Buttercup wrote:

I thought Amish wore dark colors, not light colors. Are they Mennonites?


I will have check it out.

Amish and Mennonites are different, Amish are isolated from the "outside", Mennonites not so much so.

I am Mennonite Alex is right Amish and Mennonites are different mennonites are more worldly, My group of mennonites are very modern except for our Clothes women wear Dresses and Head coverings, men wear Shirts with Buttons for the most part, But there are also Old Order Mennonites that are very Similar to Amish but yet different

JW wrote:

alexczarn wrote:

Buttercup wrote:

I thought Amish wore dark colors, not light colors. Are they Mennonites?


I will have check it out.

Amish and Mennonites are different, Amish are isolated from the "outside", Mennonites not so much so.

I am Mennonite Alex is right Amish and Mennonites are different mennonites are more worldly, My group of mennonites are very modern except for our Clothes women wear Dresses and Head coverings, men wear Shirts with Buttons for the most part, But there are also Old Order Mennonites that are very Similar to Amish but yet different

I knew that Mennonites drove cars and such, but I didn't realize they were able to use computers.. Very neat. The Mennonites here have to drive black cars. Is that the case with you, Jacob?

I know my dad ggrow up around Mennonites when he was young. He said they were the most nicest ppl ever.

I had no idea that they could use comptures either.

Yes Debbie there still lot of groups that can't use Computers and TVs i have some cousins that are in a more stricter ordnung they can't use Computers either,
As for the Color of the Vehicle does not matter in my group, My Group only excepted Vehicles in the late 70's then in 1983 they excepted the electricity
I have always wanted to visit the mennonites in Pennsylvania maybe someday soon

You should really come to Lancaster County, PA Jacob. I think you would really enjoy it.