"American Idol" - Season 7

No problem. :idance:

I do have to say I didn't like Simon's hissy fit when David Cook simply said that what he had to do was win us (the public) over and not him (Simon).
That's something I would have said because Simon started putting him down because he was a 'word nerd' and saying that the whole video about crozzword puzzles didn't help him.

How stupid is that? What does that have to do with him singing?? I thought this was a singing competition?
The question that every contestant was answering was "Something that America would be surprised to know about me is... " and that is what David shared... who knew Simon would critizise him for it... Take a chill pill Simon :bash: LOL
I don't think David was rude in what he said... he said it 'as a matter of factly' not with an attitude or stuff like that...

Okay, what happened to the girls? Nobody really outstood for me tonight. But I know there are some with really powerful voices in there.

But the ones I'm pulling for are:



Carly

Ramiele

and Kristy (She said she's a good country singer... so I would like to see that...

Seriously Carol, what the heck happened last night?!?! Good grief, I was bored silly! :sleep: The only ones I liked were the ones you mentioned, and Brooke White. I voted for her. But none of them were at their best last night, that's for sure. Oh, and I thought Sayesha did a good job last night, even though the judges didn't really like her. At least she was in TUNE! :think:

I have a feeling that when they get to the final ten or twelve, and they're voted off one by one, the guys will be out-numbering the ladies. I feel that Carly did the best last night, although I'm not a huge fan of hers. What was up with Amanda? Or should I say...........Elvira? LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I agree, Teresa.And it's fine by me! I wanted Blake last season, so I'd be all for a guy getting it this time around. I agree that Carly was best last night too...she has really good control. I'd like to hear her do a ballad now. Oh, but Amanda!! I can't believe the judges were so kind to her. I actually turned the volume down on my tv, she was so bad! I'm glad they told her how it is with her 'look'...it's just not workin'! I thought Kady Malloy was especially pitchy too...like Randy said, she just never found her note. I get frustrated when these people defend themselves after the criticism too, with comments like, "I was just having fun." Um, it's a singing competition. You can have fun, but you're supposed to be able to carry a tune while doing so.

LOL, Amy!! I agree! Simon's criticism may be a little harsh at times, but he speaks the truth. You need to have "tough" skin to be in the entertainment business. This is only the beginning stages for some of them. It will get harder as they go, so it's better to prepare them now. I've said it before, but Simon usually says what everyone is thinking, but too afraid to say.

Exactly. I know people think he can be cruel, but this is a cruel business! I'm sure there are much harsher people out there than Simon in the industry. If they can't take it, they probably shouldn't try to get into it in the first place.

Amanda was in her own planet
I don't know... to me... every song she sings sounds exactly the same...

I agreed with every opinion Simon gave last night lol

Here's my Guys Report
I Like Him Great Singer
Heard Better but i Like his Guitar
He Was Not Bad not Bad at all
Good but not my Favorite
NOT GOOD He Remided me so much of Saniaja
Great I Really Love it Tuesday Night
I Kind of Like it But he Probally Won't make it very far
Not For Me but i guess Pretty Good
Too Rockinsh for me but good
David Aruchuleta GREAT SINGER He's Not Going anywhere I Would't be Suprise if he won the whole thing

I Like it I wanna see her sing country I thought from the beginning on that she would be great at country Lets See What she's gonna do
She Was Better Last Week But I still Loved it
I Did Not Like it No Offence to anyone but her Hair looks kind of like Skunk Hair
Much better then Last Week I Loved it
Nothing Speaical for me I think she might be Leaving tonight
Not as Good as she Could of Been But I Still Like it
I think she's better at fast songs
She Was OK
I thought she was better last week But still good i like her Baby Cry
Not Good For Me

JW wrote:

I Did Not Like it No Offence to anyone but her Hair looks kind of like Skunk Hair

She really needs to find a different way to express her individuality, unless she wants to remain known as Skunk Girl. Seriously, I don't even watch the show, and I know who Skunk Girl is, because that's become her nickname among my friends who do watch. I don't know how well she sings, because the only thing they talk about is her hair. So that tells me that her hair is distracting attention from her singing - and I'm pretty sure that she'd rather have the focus on trying to win the singing competition than on her Skunk Hair.

My favorite last night was Kristy...but I agree nothing blew me away. Except for Brooks hair off course. That was really bad.

Jacob, I always love your reviews with the pics! Very cool!

I'm anxious to hear Kristy's country voice too...I'm not into country, but I just have a feeling that's her thing. I do like some country (like Maritina, Shania, and Carrie Underwood (at least some songs)...oh, and Tim McGraw).

Gin, did you mean Amanda's hair, or Brooke's? I kind of thought Brooke looked cute...she had the whole natural kind of 70's thing going on. It'll be interesting to see if Amanda takes the advice of the judges and really changes her look next week. If she's serious about winning this, she'd better!

Thanks Amy
Who Do You all think is gonna go home? I'm not sure if there are Four Going home again or not if there are Then I think Jason Yeager and It should Be Danny but i have a feeling it won't be him i like Jason but i just don't think that he's one of the top Guys

Girls
I think Alexandrea and Asia'h will go tonight as well don't forget to Watch evreyone

Jacob, your picks are my picks! Well, except for Alexandrea...I think she should go farther. I'd rather see Amanda go home first!

I think I'd vote Amanda off the island. On the guy side... who was it who sang the Doobie Brothers song?

My vote for the plane ticket ride home are.....

Guys:
Jason

Chikezie


Girls:
Amanda

Alexandrea

I Was shock with one of the girls who went home I Really like her

Yeah, I thought she* had the best performance the week before. Poor kid.

*I won't say who she is just in case anyone hasn't watched it yet.

I missed the show last night! I thought it was on from 9-10 on Thursdays...guess not! :scratch:

I was only surprised with Alexandrea...not surprised with the other 3. Alaina's not bad, and I hate to quote Simon , but I just never heard anything distinctive about her voice. I always feel worst for the youngs ones when they go though. It's not easy, I'm sure.

I Was't Suprise at all that That the other three went Home But i know that girl would of done so Well if she had gone farther But someone had too go the other three were't that bad either

I just talked to my parents and they said they thought Alaina sounded better than she'd ever sounded on that final song! They said she was crying, but as the other girls sang with her, she found her strength and then sounded great! I agree with you Jacob...sometimes we just need more time to see everyone's true potential. It's too bad, but you're right, someone has to go! (I would have MUCH rather seen Amanda or Aish'a go though ).

NO KIDDING Amy Amanada Needs too GO

It will be interseting to hear what Amanda sings next week, as well as how she looks. I think that the bottom eight was accurate last night, but Luke should have gone home before Robbie. Luke's voice just isn't a powerhouse. I guess it doesn't really matter if they go home this week or next. It wasn't like Robbie would have won anyway. Same with the ladies that were in the bottom eight. I do think that Danny has a much better voice than Sanjaya ever did. Sanjaya's voice wasn't strong enough, and Danny's could be. He carries a much better tune than Sanjaya. I'm not too impressed with the ladies anymore. None of them really stand out. The only one for me is David A. If he doesn't win, he'll definitely have a wonderful career ahead of him, just like Chris Daughtry.

Well I Had to Change my Siginuter What do you think?